Misconceptions
Here are some common misconceptions I’ve heard from students.
1. You can only see the moon at night.
2. The shape of the moon changes.
3. The moon does not rotate.
My Massive Fail
Who has sent home the moon calendar where students are supposed to draw what the moon looks like each day? Who has ever had 1/4 of their students complete it? I would have been thrilled at 1/4.
I tried my first two years teaching and I think maybe 2 out of 120 students did it. The third year, I made it optional for extra credit (the ONLY time I’ve done extra credit). One student took me up on that.
So clearly, students wouldn’t be making these observations on their own at home and joyfully bringing in their observation sheets with their expert analysis to discuss. That’s fine. Half the time you can’t see the moon anyway.
So, I took a new approach the next year using the 5E Model.
1. Engage: Observations and Oreos
Students not observing the moon from home? StarDate will flat-out show you the moon phases for each date. Phew!
- Use Double Stuff Oreos. The cream filling pulls off easily with a plastic knife (or something not sharp and appropriate for school) and maintains its shape.
- Each student needs a plate with 4 cookies.
- Label the Earth and Sun on the plate before starting.
- LIGHT starts on the RIGHT. Following the New Moon, the crescent will appear on the right.
- After the phase reaches a full moon, the phases will appear as the opposite of the one across from it as it moves back toward the new moon.
- Identify the phase names.
2. Explore: Moon Pop Model
This is an old-school activity, but it sticks around because it’s a good one. You go through some basic information about the phases of the moon and observe the changes using a model (a styrofoam ball on a pencil).
Students draw the model, identify what each item represents, identify the limitations and advantages, and then explain why the moon’s appearance seems to change when viewed from Earth.
3. Explain: Direct Teach
Watch a video from our friend, Mar Garden Science, read an included text, write in notebooks, discuss the content, and label a diagram to make sense of why the moon’s appearance seems to change.
All of these pages are in the Moon Phases Unit found in my Free Resource Library.
4. Elaborate & Evaluate
Now that students have tracked the moon’s appearance, explored the names of the phases, modeled the moon’s changing phases, and worked through why all of this happens, it’s time to go a little deeper.
In teams, students complete a sequencing challenge.
Students, in pairs, do a Moon Journal Analysis to answer questions about their moon journal and make predictions.
Independently, students complete a Moon Phases Analysis and assess their own understanding of moon phases.
Finally, students take a quiz and do an open-ended response.
All of these pages are in the Moon Phases Unit found in my Free Resource Library.
5. Moon Phases Task Cards
On the Elementary Science STAAR, students may be expected to identify a moon phase and then predict when that moon phase will occur again using a calendar. (That’s what we saw in 2026.)
In 4th grade, spend about 8 days teaching about moon phases. Go DEEP into predictions.
In 5th grade, spend 1 or 2 days reviewing how to identify the names of moon phases, sequencing the phases, and predicting the phases with a calendar.
These Test Prep Task Cards can help.
See it on TPT: Moon Phases Task Cards
Practice Makes Progress!



